Civil law contracts in public procurement: The domino effect

Authors

  • Andrejs Vilks Riga Stradins University
  • Anatolijs Krivins Daugavpils University
  • Aldona Kipane Riga Stradins University

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.34135/cejpp.355

Keywords:

automatic invalidity,, contract autonomy,, compromise (flexible) model,, functional (pragmatic) approach,, optimal model.

Abstract

The objective of this research was to determine the optimal legal model for handling the annulment of administrative acts in public procurement while balancing legality, legal certainty, good faith, and public interests. A SWOT analysis was applied to evaluate internal and external factors through four categories: strengths, weaknesses, opportunities, and threats. Four approaches were examined. The automatic invalidity approach strictly follows legality, treating unlawful acts and related contracts as invalid. The contract autonomy approach prioritises contractual stability and the protection of legitimate expectations. The compromise approach combines legality with flexibility by considering good faith and the consequences of annulment. The functional approach focuses on social expediency, preserving contracts where termination would cause disproportionate harm. Analysis of European Union case law demonstrated that modern legal practice upholds legality while also considering public benefit and practical consequences, making the compromise approach the most balanced model. Contracts may therefore remain valid despite procedural violations if annulment would create disproportionate harm. In Latvia, the functional approach prevails, emphasising efficiency, simplification of procedures, and risk minimisation in procurement processes. The findings may support further research on contractual risks, ripple effects, and safeguard mechanisms in public procurement.

Author Biographies

Anatolijs Krivins, Daugavpils University

Faculty of Humanities and Social Sciences

Daugavpils University

LV-54011, 13 Vienības Str., Daugavpils, Latvia

a-krivins@hotmail.com

 

Aldona Kipane, Riga Stradins University

 

Faculty of Social Sciences

Riga Stradins University

LV-1007, 16 Dzirciema Srt., Riga, Latvia

kipanea@gmail.com

Downloads

Published

2026-11-15